The Best Clean Eyeliners, According to Makeup Artists


Your eyes are extremely delicate so it is smart to take further precaution when selecting eye creams and the make-up you’re utilizing round your eye space. When you’ve already made the change to clean mascara, it’s time to commerce in your previous pencils for these makeup-artist really useful pure eyeliner picks.

Meet the Consultants

Kerrin Jackson, make-up artist and creator of The Makeup Refinery

Matthew Waitesmith, make-up artist and co-founder of Artis

Hadley King, M.D., a dermatologist at Skinney Med Spa and teacher on the Weill Medical Faculty of Cornell College

Mary Winkenwerder, make-up artist

Why Clear Magnificence

Likelihood is, you’ve a minimum of heard about clear magnificence, the brand new wave of magnificence merchandise which can be flipping the trade on its head. Because it seems, there is no such thing as a FDA-approval course of for cosmetics, which implies that the elements utilized in your favourite magnificence merchandise usually are not being monitored the way in which those in your meals are. Actually, U.S. regulation doesn’t require any elements being utilized in beauty merchandise, other than coloration components, to be accredited or regulated. As such, some fairly regarding chemical compounds could possibly be lurking in among the magnificence merchandise you’ve been utilizing for years. 

That is why clear magnificence is having such a second. The idea refers to beauty merchandise which can be formulated with out using doubtlessly dangerous elements akin to artificial chemical compounds. Some clear magnificence merchandise stretch even additional, offering transparency about ingredient sourcing, packaging, and sustainability to their prospects, notes Kerrin Jackson, a 4-time Emmy-nominated make-up artist and creator of The Makeup Refinery. “In advertising phrases, clear magnificence has come to characterize an entire consciousness of magnificence way of life decisions and the results of these decisions on ourselves and our better setting,” she provides.

Choosing clear magnificence is a sensible resolution, significantly in relation to the make-up you’re utilizing round your eye space, akin to eyeliner. The attention space itself is extremely delicate, particularly the pores and skin across the eye, which may be very skinny, fragile, and vulnerable to dehydration.

“Since eyeliner merchandise are used so near the attention, and contemplating how essential it’s to guard this space, it’s best to keep away from any elements that you’ll have established a sensitivity to and have a response to,” says make-up artist and co-founder of Artis, Matthew Waitesmith. “You will discover merchandise that both keep away from conventional preservative elements or hold them at a minimal.”

What to search for in a pure eyeliner

In response to magnificence specialists, when you’re purchasing for an eyeliner that falls beneath the class of “clear,” right here are some things you need to be on the lookout for. 

Free from dangerous chemical compounds

The laundry listing of chemical compounds to look out for to make sure your eyeliner is clear is sort of lengthy—it consists of parabens, aluminum, formaldehyde (sure, like in embalming), petroleum, talc, triclosan, and silica, simply to call a number of. Analysis, together with one examine printed within the journal, Molecular and Mobile Endocrinology, has linked parabens to a myriad of hormonal problems, together with most cancers [source]. 

Plant-based elements

Each time doable, Jackson recommends buying eyeliners that comprise plant-based waxes as a substitute of synthetics. “The Rhus Verniciflua Peel Wax present in W3LL People’s Fresh Lines Eyeliner Pencil is a recognized different to beeswax, for instance,” she says. “Jojoba seed oil, which is present in each the W3LL Folks Pencil I discussed and merchandise from Honest Beauty, is understood to deal with and situation the pores and skin.”

Natural, when doable

Each time you may, it’s best to hunt down the title “natural” in your clear eyeliners. If an eyeliner is licensed natural, a minimum of 95 p.c of the supplies used are natural compliant per the USDA. This implies they’re dealt with and manufactured in an natural method that doesn’t use any genetically modified organisms. It’s value declaring that this certification is sort of dear, so simply because a clear magnificence product isn’t “natural” per its label doesn’t imply it’s not really natural by USDA requirements. 

Vegan and cruelty-free

It’s an incredible factor when a clear magnificence product, akin to an eyeliner, is vegan and cruelty-free. This implies the merchandise weren’t examined on animals and don’t comprise any animal by-products (beeswax, lanolin, honey, tallow). 


A high quality clear product ought to be sustainable, that means that its manufacturing and packaging usually are not inflicting hurt to the planet. Most sustainable magnificence merchandise are available biodegradable or recycled packaging and contribute to a TerraCycle program.


Eyeliners which can be hypo-allergenic and ophthalmologist examined are the most secure on your eye space.” Which means the chances of your eyes reacting to the product are minimized and {that a} product is fragrance-free,” says Jackson.

Makeup Artists Favorite Clean Eyeliners

The most effective clear eyeliners available on the market

Listed below are some hand-picked clear eyeliners really useful by the make-up artists we interviewed.


W3LL People Fresh Lines Eye Pencil W3LL People Fresh Lines Eye Pencil

The listing of elements in a product begins with the ingredient having the biggest amount, so it’s good to see that castor seed oil is the primary on this eye pencil. Castor seed oil is protected when utilized in small doses and is a pure emollient. It’s wealthy in ricinoleic acid, a sort of monounsaturated fatty acid [source], so it helps forestall dryness round your eye space. This product can be vegan and formulated with out using harsh chemical compounds or preservatives. 

PUR Beauty On Point Eyeliner Pencil PUR Beauty On Point Eyeliner Pencil

Along with being freed from parabens, phthalates, and cyclical silicones, this self-sharpening gel eyeliner pencil is top-notch when it comes to its efficiency. “It maintains a high quality tip for exact and simple software, and the waterproof formulation stays on for lengthy put on,” says Hadley King, M.D., a dermatologist at Skinney Med Spa and scientific teacher of dermatology on the Weill Medical Faculty of Cornell College. “The formulation consists of moisturizing elements like sunflower seed oil, vitamin E, and panthenol to help the fragile pores and skin of the eyelids.” 

Butter London Power Up All Day Wear Liquid Eyeliner Butter London Power Up All Day Wear Liquid Eyeliner

When you’re extra of a liquid liner particular person, this one has a easy and creamy texture and a versatile precision tip, which makes for straightforward software. “Along with being vegan, cruelty-free, and paraben-free, this one makes use of the pure ingredient glycerin, which hydrates the pores and skin, and polymers that add to its sturdiness,” says Dr. King. It’s additionally water resistant, which is right for lengthy put on. 

NakedPoppy Clean Liquid Eyeliner NakedPoppy Clean Liquid Eyeliner

This eyeliner bears the EWG VERIFIED™ mark, which implies it meets the Environmental Working Group’s strict requirements for well being and security—avoiding any and all elements on their “Unacceptable Record.” Dr. King is a fan of the elements it does use, together with cornflower water, which soothes the pores and skin, and iron oxide, which gives pure pigment. “This product is cruelty-free and freed from parabens, phthalates, and cyclical silicones,” she says. “It additionally has a exact tip for straightforward software and doesn’t smudge.”

Honest Beauty Vibeliner Honest Beauty Vibeliner

For lower than $10, you may rating a high-quality pencil eyeliner made with out dangerous chemical compounds like carbon black pigment, which has been discovered to have carcinogenic properties. “Sincere actually does dwell as much as its identify with full transparency about what’s in and what isn’t in its merchandise,” says Jackson. “What I really like about Sincere is that, regardless of utilizing plant-based elements and few artificial chemical compounds, there is no such thing as a compromise on high quality—and they’re nonetheless inexpensive as effectively.”

Earth Lab Vegan Mineral Eye Pencil Earth Lab Vegan Mineral Eye Pencil

Make-up artist Mary Winkenwerder is an enormous fan of this pencil eyeliner that produces wealthy coloration with out fading, wears effectively for a very long time, and has a flawless software. “Whereas liquid eyeliner is extra well-liked with high-fashion stencil eye designs, this one steps in and produces a usable fill-in for fundamental stencil eye lining designs,” she provides. 

bareMinerals Maximist Liquid Eyeliner bareMinerals Maximist Liquid Eyeliner

When you get pleasure from carrying extremely outlined traces round your eyes, Winkenwerder recommends this clear eyeliner, which might be worn on naked eyes or drawn over accomplished eye shadow statements. “All of your clear magnificence and high-fashion eyeliner expectations come true with this product,” she says. It’s freed from parabens, gluten, perfume, SLS, PEG, and the listing goes on. It’s additionally cruelty-free and vegan. 

The best clean eyeliners on the market

Images by Sujeeth Potla and Kelly Sikkema on Unsplash


Source link


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here